PiesDurban Indian

Chicken And Mushroom Pies

Make authentic Chicken And Mushroom Pies with this foolproof recipe. Packed with rich traditional flavor, step-by-step photos, and cooking tips by Denisiya on EatMee Recipes.

4.8·25 reader ratings
Rate this recipe:
D
By DenisiyaPublished on May 20, 2025
Chicken And Mushroom Pies
⏱️
Prep Time15 mins
🍳
Cook Time87 mins
⌛
Total Time102 mins
🍽️
ServingsMakes 8 Medium Sized Pies
Denisiya on YouTube @eatmeerecipes
@eatmeerecipesOfficial Channel

Cook Along With Denisiya on YouTube

Join over 60,000+ home chefs for weekly authentic Durban Indian cook-alongs, Instant Pot masterclasses, and family heritage recipes.

Subscribe (Free)60,000+ Subscribers • 900+ Videos

This Recipe Makes 8 Medium Sized Pies

A Classic Combo with Timeless Appeal

Chicken and mushroom pies are a staple in many kitchens for a reason. Tender chunks of chicken mingle with earthy mushrooms in a creamy, flavorful sauce, all tucked into a flaky, golden pastry crust. It’s rustic, hearty, and endlessly satisfying.

Whether you’re whipping up a big family dinner or preparing individual pies to freeze for easy midweek meals, this dish always delivers.

Tips for Pie Perfection

  • Don’t rush the filling: Let the sauce simmer gently so the flavors meld together beautifully.

  • Cool before filling: Always let your filling cool before spooning it into the pastry. Hot filling can make your crust soggy.

  • Egg wash magic: For that glossy, golden crust, brush the top with a beaten egg before baking.

Why Use Shortcrust Pastry for Chicken and Mushroom Pies?

Shortcrust pastry is the ideal foundation for a hearty filling like chicken and mushroom. Unlike puff pastry, which is light and layered, shortcrust is more robust and crumblier, offering a firm structure that holds up well under the weight of rich, creamy fillings.

Its buttery flavor and flaky texture add depth to every bite, while its sturdiness ensures the pie maintains its shape and doesn’t become soggy as it bakes. For savory pies that need a reliable, delicious base—like a classic chicken and mushroom—shortcrust pastry is the perfect match.

Serve & Savor

Serve your chicken and mushroom pie piping hot, straight from the oven, with a side of buttery mashed potatoes or steamed green veggies. And don’t forget the gravy—because more sauce is always a good idea.

Final Thoughts

In a world of quick meals and endless food fads, there’s something beautifully grounding about a homemade pie. Chicken and mushroom pies remind us to slow down, savor each bite, and share the table with those we love.

So, roll up your sleeves, preheat the oven, and bring a little comfort to your kitchen tonight.

🥗

Ingredients

Scale:
Base Yield: Makes 8 Medium Sized Pies
Advertisement
👩‍🍳

Step-by-Step Instructions

42 Steps
  1. Step 1

    Start off by making the Chicken and Mushroom filling. Peel and finely chop the onion.

    Step 1 visual guide
  2. Step 2

    If using a variety of mushrooms, it is advisable to remove the gills from brown and portobello mushrooms, as they can impart a slightly bitter flavor and may affect the color of the filling. The gills of button mushrooms, however, may be retained, as they are milder and less likely to alter the dish. For a cleaner presentation and smoother texture, I also chose to peel the outer layer of the mushroom caps—though this step is optional. Once prepared, the mushrooms were finely chopped for even distribution throughout the filling.

    Step 2 visual guide
  3. Step 3

    Rinse the chicken breasts, cut them into small cubes and place into a bowl.

    Step 3 visual guide
  4. Step 4

    Season the chicken with salt, fine black pepper, garlic powder, chicken spice, dried thyme and dried parsley.

    Step 4 visual guide
  5. Step 5

    Mix together until the chicken is thoroughly coated in the spices.

    Step 5 visual guide
  6. Step 6

    To a pot on medium-high heat, add in the olive oil. Once the oil is hot, add in the seasoned chicken.

    Step 6 visual guide
  7. Step 7

    Spread out the chicken and allow it to cook for 5 minutes or until it changes colour.

    Step 7 visual guide
  8. Step 8

    Next, add in the butter, chopped onions and the mushrooms.

    Step 8 visual guide
  9. Step 9

    Mix together and sauté for a further 5 minutes.

    Step 9 visual guide
  10. Step 10

    Now its time to add in the crushed garlic. Adding it at this point will prevent it from burning. Mix and allow to simmer for 2 minutes.

    Step 10 visual guide
  11. Step 11

    Thereafter, I added in some corn flour as this will allow it to thicken slightly.

    Step 11 visual guide
  12. Step 12

    Stir the corn flour in until it is completely dissolved without any lumps.

    Step 12 visual guide
  13. Step 13

    Now for the saucy part – pour in the cream. I have used long life cream but feel free to use fresh cream.

    Step 13 visual guide
  14. Step 14

    Stir in the cream until it all blends in together.

    Step 14 visual guide
  15. Step 15

    You will notice the mixture becomes a lot thicker as it simmers. Add in ¼ cup of water as this will loosen the mixture.

    Step 15 visual guide
  16. Step 16

    The mixture shouldn’t be too thick or too runny. At this point adjust salt according to taste.

    Step 16 visual guide
  17. Step 17

    Turn off the heat and allow the Chicken and Mushroom filling to cool completely or else the hot filling will melt the pastry.

    Step 17 visual guide
  18. Step 18

    I have used 10cm foil tins which I got from Westpack.

    Step 18 visual guide
  19. Step 19

    The pastries should be thawed in the refrigerator beforehand. For this recipe I used Woolworths Puff Pastry and Today’s Shortcrust pastry.

    Step 19 visual guide
  20. Step 20

    Start by unrolling the Shortcrust Pastry. This is going to be used as the base of the pies.

    Step 20 visual guide
  21. Step 21

    Use a cutter or a lid like I have which is a bit bigger than the circumference of the foil tin.

    Step 21 visual guide
  22. Step 22

    Cut around the lid or cutter to form a circle.

    Step 22 visual guide
  23. Step 23

    You should get about 3 circles out of this.

    Step 23 visual guide
  24. Step 24

    Please do not roll out the pastry to try and make more shapes. Gently fold the pastry with your hands and press down to create more circles. You should get 8 circles in total.

    Step 24 visual guide
  25. Step 25

    Place the Shortcrust Pastry circles one at a time into the foil tins. Press down firmly so it covers the surface & outer edges

    Step 25 visual guide
  26. Step 26

    Flip the tin over & cut off excess pastry.

    Step 26 visual guide
  27. Step 27

    Continue this process until all the tins have the pastry base.

    Step 27 visual guide
  28. Step 28

    Add the Chicken and Mushroom filling.

    Step 28 visual guide
  29. Step 29

    Unroll the Puff Pastry. Do not roll it with a rolling pin – leave it as is.

    Step 29 visual guide
  30. Step 30

    Take one of the foil tins and use this as a guide to cut the circles for the lids of the pie.

    Step 30 visual guide
  31. Step 31

    You should get the whole 8 circles cut out from the pastry – the excess can be used to create shapes for the top of the pies if preferred.

    Step 31 visual guide
  32. Step 32

    Crack the egg into a bowl and beat using a fork.

    Step 32 visual guide
  33. Step 33

    Lightly brush some egg wash around the edge of the pie base.

    Step 33 visual guide
  34. Step 34

    Place the puff pastry lids over & gently press down the edges so the lids can stay put.

    Step 34 visual guide
  35. Step 35

    Use the tip of a fork to crimp the edges of the pastry & pierce the fork in the middle of the lid so steam can escape when baking.

    Step 35 visual guide
  36. Step 36

    These can now be packed & frozen to consume whenever you want them.

    Step 36 visual guide
  37. Step 37

    If you want to bake them, preheat your oven to 200° Celsius. Brush the remaining egg wash over the pies.

    Step 37 visual guide
  38. Step 38

    Bake for 10 minutes at 200° Celsius – this will allow the puff pastry to rise. After 10 minutes lower the heat to 180° Celsius & allow to bake for 30 minutes or until golden.

    Step 38 visual guide
  39. Step 39

    Alternatively, these can be air fried at 180° Celsius for 20 minutes, then flip them over & air fry for a further 5 minutes just to make sure the bottom cooks as the element in the air fryer is only at the top.

    Step 39 visual guide
  40. Step 40

    Allow them to cool for a bit on the baking tray before serving.

    Step 40 visual guide
  41. Step 41

    The bottom side of the pies should be thoroughly cooked – some have mentioned that their pastry didn’t cook through so this would depend on your oven. I would suggest flipping them over to make sure it is cooked or pop them into your air fryer (flipped).

    Step 41 visual guide
  42. Step 42

    These pies are perfect for lunch boxes, a quick dinner, ramadan preps, etc.

    Step 42 visual guide
💡

Mum's Pro Tips

Don’t rush the filling

Let the sauce simmer gently so the flavors meld together beautifully.

Cool before filling

Always let your filling cool before spooning it into the pastry. Hot filling can make your crust soggy.

Egg wash magic

For that glossy, golden crust, brush the top with a beaten egg before baking.

Shortcrust pastry is the ideal foundation for a hearty filling like chicken and mushroom. Unlike puff pastry, which is light and layered, shortcrust is more robust and crumblier, offering a firm structure that holds up well under the weight of rich, creamy fillings.

Its buttery flavor and flaky texture add depth to every bite, while its sturdiness ensures the pie maintains its shape and doesn’t become soggy as it bakes. For savory pies that need a reliable, delicious base—like a classic chicken and mushroom—shortcrust pastry is the perfect match.

Video Tutorial

Watch How It's Made

Follow along with Denisiya's step-by-step video guide for Chicken And Mushroom Pies.

Advertisement

Frequently Asked Questions & Cooking Tips

Expert kitchen guidance and troubleshooting for making the best Chicken And Mushroom Pies

Can I adjust the spice and chilli levels in Chicken And Mushroom Pies?

Absolutely! You can easily tailor the heat by increasing or reducing the chili powder and fresh chilies to suit your family’s palate without compromising the authentic flavor profile.

Can I freeze leftovers of this dish?

Yes, you can freeze Chicken And Mushroom Pies in an airtight, freezer-safe container for up to 2 to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before gently reheating.

How do I reheat leftovers for best flavor?

Reheat gently on the stovetop over low heat with a splash of water, or in the microwave covered with a damp paper towel to retain moisture.

Denisiya - Founder & Chef at EatMee Recipes
About the Creator

Meet Denisiya

Hi, I'm Denisiya! Food lover, recipe developer, and founder of EatMee Recipes. I specialize in authentic South African Durban Indian cuisine, comforting curries, and modern Instant Pot adaptations. Every recipe on this site is tested in my personal kitchen to ensure you get mouth-watering, foolproof results every time.

Comments & Community

0

Have you tried this recipe or have questions for Denisiya? Join the conversation below.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts on this recipe!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *