We Value Your Culinary Privacy
EatMee Recipes uses cookies to provide a personalized browsing experience, analyze recipe popularity, and serve relevant ads. You can review our full disclosure in our Privacy Policy.
Make authentic Chicken & Mushroom Pie with this foolproof recipe. Packed with rich traditional flavor, step-by-step photos, and cooking tips by Denisiya on EatMee Recipes.

Chicken & Mushroom Pie is the simplest of all pies. It includes chicken & mushrooms of course which is enrobed in a creamy white sauce, covered in puff pastry & baked until golden.
As a kid, Chicken & Mushroom Pie was by far my favourite, it always seemed to just hit the spot. South Africa definitely has thee best variation of these pies but I add a few more ingredients in my recipe to make it a little more boujee.
These pies can be made in ramekins or in pie foils to make individual serving portion or you can opt to making a large one as I have. Another roll of puff pastry or shortcrust pastry can be used as the base of the pie as I used just one roll to cover the top.
Chicken & Mushroom Pie Ingredients:
For the chicken & mushroom filling:
For the Béchamel sauce (White Sauce):

Rinse the chicken fillets.

Cut the chicken into cubes & place in a bowl.

Season the chicken with salt to taste & ground black pepper.

Add in the oregano & sweet basil.

Add in the garlic powder & ginger powder. I prefer using the powder for this dish instead of the fresh paste or crushed alternative.

Use your fingertips & rub the spices into the chicken.

Peel & slice the mushrooms. Set aside in a bowl.

Add 2 tablespoons vegetable oil to a medium sized pot/pan. When oil is hot enough drop in the seasoned chicken.

Stir every now & again.

Cover with a lid & allow the chicken to cook for 10 minutes.

After 10 minutes, notice the excess water from the chicken, do not drain it as this is a stock that will give it added flavour.

Give it a stir & add in the sliced mushrooms.

Mix well.

Cover with a lid & allow to cook for another 10 minutes.

After cooking for 10 minutes, give it a stir & turn off the heat.

Set aside until ready to use.
Next begin preparing the Béchamel sauce (White Sauce).

To another pot, add in the butter & allow to melt on medium heat

Once the butter has melted, add in the flour.

Stir in the flour continuously so that it doesn’t burn.

Once all the flour has diminished, gradually pour in the milk or cream. I prefer using milk over cream as I find the cream tends to curdle much faster, ruining the sauce.

Mix well until it thickens.

It should form a creamy sauce.

Add in freshly grated nutmeg & salt to taste.

Mix well.

Turn off the heat when the sauce is of the right consistency. If it is too thick, add in more milk or cream. Add in the Parmesan cheese. This is optional but adding it sure does make a whole lot of difference in taste.

Mix well.

Pour the sauce into the pot of cooked chicken & mushroom.

Stir in the sauce.

Pour the Chicken & Mushroom filling into a pie casserole.
Preheat the oven to 180° Celsius.

Crack an egg into a bowl.

Beat well using a fork or a whisk & set aside.

Sprinkle a little flour on a working surface & open out the puff pastry.

Roll the puff pastry with a rolling pin just enough so that it can cover the casserole. If it’s a perfect fit for your casserole then there is no need to roll it out. Next, I placed a pot lid over the pastry that is just a little bigger than the circumference of my casserole.

Use a knife & cut around the lid.

Place the cut out pastry over the casserole.

Trim off the excess pastry.

I used my fingers to tuck & crease the ends of the pastry to create a more rustic look. Thereafter brush the beaten egg over.

It can be left as is & baked or you may decorate it if you want to make it a bit more fancy.

I had leftover puff pastry, so I used a cookie cutter & created shapes. I then placed these shapes over & brushed some egg wash over.

Thereafter, sprinkle some sesame seeds & poppy seeds.

Bake for 35-40 minutes until golden.

The Chicken & Mushroom Pie should be golden brown.

Serve whilst hot.
Follow along with Denisiya's step-by-step video guide for Chicken & Mushroom Pie.
Expert kitchen guidance and troubleshooting for making the best Chicken & Mushroom Pie
Absolutely! You can easily tailor the heat by increasing or reducing the chili powder and fresh chilies to suit your family’s palate without compromising the authentic flavor profile.
Yes, you can freeze Chicken & Mushroom Pie in an airtight, freezer-safe container for up to 2 to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before gently reheating.
Reheat gently on the stovetop over low heat with a splash of water, or in the microwave covered with a damp paper towel to retain moisture.

Hi, I'm Denisiya! Food lover, recipe developer, and founder of EatMee Recipes. I specialize in authentic South African Durban Indian cuisine, comforting curries, and modern Instant Pot adaptations. Every recipe on this site is tested in my personal kitchen to ensure you get mouth-watering, foolproof results every time.
Have you tried this recipe or have questions for Denisiya? Join the conversation below.
This recipe came out perfect! I don’t like being in the kitchen, but this is a winner. Will be making it more often.
So happy to hear. Glad you enjoyed it xx
Hi there,
Thank you for your awesome recipes. Definitely trying this recipe tonight, will tag you on instagram.
Wooow this receipe is so easy ..I really love it👌👌👌👌.
Thank you so much for this receipe….it’s very very easy💕💕💕
Thank you so much
Leave a Comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *